Whenever the Romulan Neutral Zone comes up inStar Trek, it’s usually a prelude to a fight that’ll bring out the worst sides of each opponent until blood is shed. A Starfleet vessel might illegally enter its borders under suspicion of war crimes, or a Romulan vessel might hide within it to avoid being suspected of said war crimes. This is the plotline ofmultiple episodes ofStar Trek: The Original Series. Either way, by the time the Neutral Zone comes up in conversation, it’s usually too late to avoid disaster.
Contrary to popular belief, though, it was created to minimize violence between the United Federation of Planets and the Romulan Star System. The two primarily existed in different quadrants, but were apparently still too close for comfort. It seemed that they could hardly stand living so close to each other without constantly clashing. So, the Romulan Neutral Zone existed as extra political padding around the border along the Beta Quadrant. Any attempts to cross into it without prior approval would result in dire consequences. While the intentions toward conflict resolution were strong, the maintenance of the Romulan Neutral Zone never really lived up to its own purpose.
RELATED:Star Trek: Important Moments In The Federation’s History
Starfleet Versus The Romulans
ThroughoutStar Trek, the Federation has rarely had a good relationship with the Romulans. It got so bad that no one in Starfleet would even know what Romulans looked like until an unfortunately timed reveal inThe Original Series. Prior to the establishment of the Romulan Neutral Zone, the two governments spent four years turning their hostilities into increasingly bloody battles. They were like the galactic version of rival street gangs. After a while, it didn’t matter who was responding to what instance of wrongdoing. The only thing that mattered was one-upping each other and making sure they caused maximum damage along the way.
Worse, their willingness to increase the harm they inflicted on each other was growing every day. It endangered innocents in the process, as seen inStar Trek: Enterprise. It all came to a head in 2160. The Federation had provided diplomatic assistance toward mending the discord betweenVulcans, Tellarites, and Andorians. In return, these governments were key in providing Starfleet with backup during the Battle of Cheron. In season 4, episode 13, “United,” the Romulans tried to break up this alliance, only to make it stronger by presenting themselves as a threat toward any attempts at peace. The battle led to the Federation declaring victory, but it was years before they achieved anything resembling peace.
The Treaty of Algeron
Technically speaking, the Battle of Cheron led to the Federation and the Romulans coordinating via radio to establish the Romulan Neutral Zone. Both parties were subject to the rule that unauthorized entry was basically a declaration of war. However,Star Trekwould specifically refer to it as the Romulan Neutral Zone since it was located in Romulan space.The Federation placed eight outpostsnear the Romulan Neutral Zone to make sure the Romulans kept up their end of the bargain. Unfortunately, neither Federation oversight nor the zone itself was enough to stop more lives from being lost in this seemingly endless moral battle of ego and will.
InThe Original Series, the Enterprise went helm-to-helm in a fight against a Romulan ship in season 1, episode 8, “Balance of Terror.” They suspected the ship of attacking the Federation outposts alongside the Romulan Neutral Zone and they were right.Serpents Among the Ruinsis aStar Treknovel that describes the Tomed Incident as being instrumental to the Federation and the Romulans signing the Treaty of Algeron. It extended the pre-existing rules of the Romulan Neutral Zone to ban Federation research or the use of cloaking devices, since either would give Starfleet a reason to enter the Romulan Neutral Zone.
Chaos In The Beta Quadrant
Still, bad blood is bad blood. Stopping the Federation from being in conflict with the Romulans seemed almost impossible at one point. Starfleet would send ships into the Beta Quadrant to investigate suspicious activity or engage in it themselves. InThe Next Generation, the Enterprise illegally enters the Romulan Neutral Zone at the behest of a Romulan informant in season 3, episode 10, “The Defector.” Many Romulans would consistently prioritize their lust for violence over respect for political boundaries. InVoyager,Romulans hijacked a Starfleet shipin season 4, episode 14, “Message in a Bottle,” to make it seem like the Federation had illegally entered the Romulan Neutral Zone.
While a bigger threat would later unite them, it took a bit of finessing to finally bring them together.Deep Space Nineintroduced the Dominion as a nearly unstoppable force. The Founders, Vorta, Jem’Hadar, and other Dominion allies were such a terrifying collective that it brought the Romulans and the Federation together as ‘partners in crisis.’ Season 3, episode 1, “The Search, Part I,” even saw the Federation being gifted with the use of acloaking device on the USS Defiant– with a few stipulations, of course. Temporary partnership aside, the Romulan Neutral Zone continued to be its own special source of mayhem until the very end.
The Fate Of The Romulan Neutral Zone
In 2387, theStar Trekuniverse was a different place than it had been over 200 years prior. Many of the original captains had moved on – to the next career, or the other side of life. Georgi La Forge (LeVart Burton) was running a Starfleet museum. Most curiously of all,the Romulan Neutral Zone collapsedinStar Trek: Picard,and the Romulan Star System was replaced with the Romulan Free State. It was a total game changer that altered the political landscape of the galaxy. In fact, the franchise will probably continue exploring the long-lasting effects in the storylines of many TV shows and movies to come.
While it was up and running, though, the Romulan Neutral Zone was the center of much political intrigue and drama. It left many Starfleet officers questioning their moral compass even as it left fans with the stereotype of Romulans being sneaky, devious, and bloodthirsty. AsStar Trekchanges, so does the many worlds it has created over time. Maybe it will rise again one day, or maybe the real Romulan Neutral Zone is thefriendsenemies that characters made along the way.
